> ANY - Thoughts on ACAAN from a Common Magician by Carl Irwin

The best effect was not an ACAAN Report this review
Verified buyer Pro Privacy ON (login to see reviewer names) on February 16th, 2023
I, unlike many magicians, am not a fan of Asi's ACAAN. I think the move happens at the wrong time. These versions of ACAAN require no shifts. Some require no sleights at all. The sleights required to do every effect in the book are Running cards, Under-spread Cull, False Shuffle, Double lift and top peek. Besides the double lift, these are all taught in detail.

If you have watched Carl's channel, you will know some of these methods. But there are also some very good versions of ACAAN here he has not taught. I would say these are the best effects in the book.

You also get the explanation for his stack, which is supposed to be easy to memorize. The stack is perfectly functional for all of the effects in the book, but I would not recommend it for serious memdeck practitioners. All the memdeck tricks in this book will work with any stack.

Ratings for all Effects:

“ANY” No sleights required. No complex calculations. You could use a crib for the memdeck if you wanted a version with no memory work. 4/5

“CHANCE INTRODUCTION” An out to get the perfect ACAAN. Sometimes. 5/5

“ANY - COURT CARD STACK” Small stack method. This is the one Carl Says he uses most often. 4/5

“ANY… MORE” A variation of the above trick with less equivoque and more sleight of hand. 3/5

“GOING HOME” The best effect in this book. The spectator names any card, and that is the only card in position for new deck order. There is hardly any sleight of hand. 5/5

“QUARTER TRUTH” A small stack version of ACAAN. The method here is nothing new, but it definitely works well for spectators. 3/5

“FILING SUIT” A gambling style presentation makes this one feel different from the others. It uses a small stack only. 4/5

“CUT IT OUT” This version is pure bluff. I don't like it that much. The reason is because you have to make the presentation about David Berglas and ACAAN for it to make sense. Carl says this is his go-to method. 3/5

“LONG DISTANCE CALL” Not a huge fan of this one. Too much handling of the deck for me. But the effect does work fine. There isn't any thing wrong with it per se. 3/5

“DEJA VU” A spectator thinks of a number. Then they look at the card at that number. Then, despite the deck being shuffled, the card is still at that number. This is all from a shuffled deck. This one will fool some magicians because of the lack of direct control. You never know their card and number till the end of the trick, when the deck is in their hands. 4.5/5

“HIVE MIND” The method alone is okay, but the presentation is what makes it brilliant. Probably the most compelling presentation I have seen for ACAAN. It is easy and uses a shuffled deck. The only con is that you need multiple spectators. 5/5

“ALL IN THE CARDS” This one is designed for a filmed performance with a spectator there (not zoom). It will look impossible to the people who watch the video later. 4/5

“ALL IN THE MOMENT” Same as above but Impromptu. Carl does not prefer this method. 4/5

Totally worth it for all fans of ACAAN, as well as people who don't do ACAAN want a more compelling but easy version of ACAAN to add to their repertoire.

Add a comment
Bestsellers
See all bestsellers



Act Builder beta



     Get To Know Us

     Shipping and Store Policies

     Need Help?

Home | About Penguin Magic | The Penguin Foundation

Mail orders: Penguin Magic, 3299 Monier Circle, Unit A, Rancho Cordova, CA 95742
Call us at 800-880-2592 | International Dial: +1 707-317-6733

© 2002-2023 Penguin Magic. All Rights Reserved.
We hope you found the magic tricks you were looking for!