> TA: True Astonishment by Paul Harris (Box Set)

You have to face the facts Report this review
Pro Privacy ON (login to see reviewer names) on July 13th, 2009
Just for background, I have been actively performing for 4 1/2 years now, approx. 2 years at the Magic Castle, so I am no amateur giving a review. I, and along other performers, have seen Paul's other work, The Art of Astonishment , which was really amazing and at the same time really funny. But in contrast to see this product is "A REAL LETDOWN". Others who have bought this dvd will acknowledge this.

First, some of the effects are not practical or take TOO much set-up every time to perform. Second, and let me stress this, that there are TOO many gimmicks. Some of which you have to make, others you have to give away (since they signed it). Other effects are just not possible to do unless you have these objects. For me as a performer, it is good to have effects that are practical, simple, and, what I was desiring, a lot of impromptu work.

What I had noticed was that Paul Harris is not in any of the actual performances from what I had watched so far. For a lot of the performances it was Bro Gilbert, or Wayne H. among others. This does not hurt the quality of the performance...for the most part. The only trouble I had was when Bro would continually overemphasize "the already known". For example, "this is a normal pack of cards" among others examples you will find. It was really annoying because you just wanted him to get to the point. Third, and this point can be debated. When you are "watching" many of the performances from when Bro Gilbert is on the beach, it is VERY hard to focus on his performances,because frankly many of the women are in bikinis. I am not focusing on the trick but rather am "being distracted", and lose the whole idea of what is happening.

Forth, for some, if not many of the tricks, there is no logical reason for why some of the objects are used. Since there is no reason, it makes people question WHY you took out that object. A good example is in one effect, the name escapes me, where you say to the spectator if it would be amazing if jumped to the pocket. When it does not work, you instantly say "then let me do something with some cards". Get the point?

In conclusion, I am not proud of my purchase. I do not like to be held down by objects that are necessities to performing the effect. I like to perform just as if I was "On the spot" (even though sounding cliche). A true and what I call "real" magician is one who carries nothing more than a pack of cards in their pocket with little or no set-up, a few good jokes or patter lines to amplify every trick he does, and miracles that I personally believe are powerful because they did not need the aid of some object, tool, etc. to make it possible. If you are swaying on buying this product I say you should put your money to good use and check out instead Paul's Art of Astonishments collection. There you will find Paul's real potential and what he should REALLY be remembered for.

Report this comment
magic1961
Feb 23rd 2018 5:25am
Paul Harris is one of the trail blazers of close up magic. This set, is worth the money at $300. 9 DVD's plus gimmicks, pen and Lubor's Lens, which on its own is a $30 value, adds up to a great value and not to mention the puzzle box it is all packaged in. If you are a student of magic, this set is the very best of Paul Harris and given that you put in the time to study each effect and learn the underlying principles, what you get out of this package is worth well over the price. Oh, and keep your eyes off those bikinis and focus on the magic!

Add a comment
Bestsellers
See all bestsellers



Act Builder beta



     Get To Know Us

     Shipping and Store Policies

     Need Help?

Home | About Penguin Magic | The Penguin Foundation

Mail orders: Penguin Magic, 3299 Monier Circle, Unit A, Rancho Cordova, CA 95742
Call us at 800-880-2592 | International Dial: +1 707-317-6733

© 2002-2023 Penguin Magic. All Rights Reserved.
We hope you found the magic tricks you were looking for!