I bought 'Sherlockian' as a prerequisite to instructional DVD released by Ben under the same name. I
have found many pro's and its fair share of con's, but all in all I find it to be a great supplement
to anyone who is (1)Studying mentalism or (2) looking to learn and/or apply another level of
audience management to their act.
PRO's:Honestly, its a really great booklet and
scratches the surface of simple cold reading and it's applications. It makes you realize that simply
paying attention to small things your audience wouldn't think nor make a connection to can open many
new doors within your act. It puts you on a different level of thinking as opposed to you normal
spectator or laymen. Ben does a great job at laying out the foundation to learn how to read body
language and apply it from not only a mentally but through magic as well. It doesn't come
overnight... none of the things Ben Teaches in the booklet are "Pick up & Go" Effects. You have to
use trial and Error to figure out what works best for you. This in itself helps build character as a
performer and help you understand your audience. "Three truths and a lie" is a great impromptu
routine that not only teaches you real lie detection tactics, and once you get use to knowing what
to look for and how to do it in a manner that is comfortable to you, its a great go-to effect. it
took me about a week and a half of dedicated attempts with random people before I got into the swing
of things, And I was making pretty accurate hits after just a couple of days.
CON's: It's
already been touched on in previous reviews, but I'll say it as well. It isn't "Prop-free", but that
doesn't we don't have 3/4's of the things he talks about using as props lying around our house. The
fact that it isn't propless seems to rub a lot of people the wrong way, and I don't get it. Some of
the dialogue can be a little difficult to follow, but its nothing that taking some notes as you go
couldn't fix.
Like I said, all in all its a great booklet if you want to (1) better your
skills as a mentalist, (2) Learn some great ways to read body language and how to apply it to a
magic/ Mental routine, and (3) learn some amazing ways to separate the liars from your audience, but
learn how to make incredibly accurate deductions.