I signed back onto Penguin to order Identity for a friend, and as I scrolled down, it seems everyone
has given it one star for a couple of really stupid reason. I have performed the effect way over 30
times since it was released, and only ONCE did I ever get caught, or have someone figure out the
method. When they figured Identity out, it was because I was performing the Identity Extended, where
you have the mark jump from card to card. After that, I went home and made the Maxed Out version.
THIS is the routine that no one can figure out how it's done. I even went to my local magic store,
and performed the effect for him. He had never seen the effect, and when I was finished, his jaw was
on the floor, and he told me he hasn't be fooled by a card effect in YEARS.
What I think
people don't understand that it's not the effect's fault, but the performer's fault for failing the
effect. Sorry to sound harsh, but this effect, like all others need a fair amount of practice. Use
the Maxed Out version, and it makes everything so much stronger.
So to all the people who
are reading all these negative reviews, take into consideration that this effect DOES still need
practice. Practice, practice and practice, which is what I have done, and I haven't been caught ONCE
except for when I did the extended version. This effect is very powerful, so if you're willing to
practice the effect, you'll love it even more once you perform it for someone and then they
literally FREAK OUT.
So, in closing you really should pick up this effect and be the judge
yourself. This isn't a self working trick, but after about a week of practicing the effect for maybe
45mins to 60mins a day, then you will be ready to show this bad arse effect to real, lay audiences,
and like I said, they will FLIP OUT at the end.