> Chop Shop by John Bannon

Okay, but not my cup of tea Report this review
Verified buyer Pro Privacy ON (login to see reviewer names) on February 8th, 2024
First of all, let me say that I love John Bannon. My first magic set was his Move Zero DVD set and I still do some tricks from that. That was, in fact, a big motivating factor for me buying this trick. After playing with it, it's a fine trick I suppose but it has a discrepancy that I just can't get past.

At the beginning, you ostensibly have 3 cards. At the end, you have 4. Even disregarding the ones you put in your pocket, it is still obvious that there were always more than 3 cards in play, because, that's just the way it's presented, it's needed to get the "kicker ending".

Even if the audience is unaware of what an EC is, they still must intuitively know that the method boils down to hiding extra cards. The fourth card had to come from somewhere. In the tutorial they say that some might find working with that many cards is "distasteful", and I guess I'm one of them. So I'm deducting one point for that.

I'm deducting another point because I felt that the instructions just kind of assumed you were already familiar with magic, it was clear it was not produced to rote beginners, which kind of shocked me due to my previous experience with Bannon. The instructions just didn't seem top notch. This doesn't affect me, but I can see how it might others.

Anyway I hope everyone enjoys their purchases, but I already know enough tricks in this vein that I think it's going to go in the drawer.

Report this comment
robh913
Feb 15th 2024 6:47am
Maybe I'm missing something. In my handling of this, I start out with three jokers and a queen. So, it starts with 4 and ends with 4. Yes, they may suspect there are more cards, but at the end, when you do the surprise reveal, they are shocked.

Report this comment
matu4251
Sep 17th 2024 11:50am
You're always supposed to have 4 cards. When doing Elmsley Counts you're presenting 4 cards. There is no discrepancy: for the spectator you start with 4 cards(3 jokers and a queen) and you finish with 4 cards (the 4 aces).

Add a comment
Bestsellers
See all bestsellers



Act Builder beta



     Get To Know Us

     Shipping and Store Policies

     Need Help?

Home | About Penguin Magic | The Penguin Foundation

Mail orders: Penguin Magic, 3299 Monier Circle, Unit A, Rancho Cordova, CA 95742
Call us at 800-880-2592 | International Dial: +1 707-317-6733

© 2002-2023 Penguin Magic. All Rights Reserved.
We hope you found the magic tricks you were looking for!